City St George’s academic calls for better measures of deep and complex poverty to assess the impact of child poverty policy.

By Eve Lacroix (Senior Communications Officer), Published

Dr Matt Barnes delivered oral evidence in the House of Commons on Wednesday 15 April as part of an Inquiry into the Government’s Child Poverty Strategy.

The session was part of a joint inquiry between the Education and the Work and Pensions Committees with the goal of scrutinising the Government’s strategy to tackle child poverty in the UK.

At the start of April, the Government scrapped its two-child limit on Universal Credit, which it argues will lift 450,000 children out of poverty compared with previous forecasts.

Dr Barnes is a Senior Lecturer in Sociology at City St George’s, University of London and was selected to provide oral evidence because of his academic research into poverty.

He is the co-lead of the University’s new Centre for Poverty and Innovation at City St George’s, where he will focus on research around deep and complex poverty.

Fellow witnesses providing expert evidence at the Inquiry were:

  • Baroness Ruth Lister, Emeritus Professor of Social Policy at Loughborough University
  • Edward McPherson, Senior Consultant at WPI Economics
  • Professor Ruth Patrick, Professor of Public and Social Policy at University of Glasgow

Understanding deep and complex poverty

During the Inquiry session, Dr Barnes identified deep poverty as a key issue for the Government to tackle.

Factors contributing to poverty can include low-paid or insecure work, unstable housing, disability, debt and caring responsibilities.

These factors often interact; caring responsibilities may limit a parent’s ability to take on better-paid full-time work, which in turn can affect their housing security.

When a family is experiencing a combination of these issues persistently over a number of years, they are considered to be in deep poverty.

“People in poverty don’t have the same circumstances,” Dr Barnes told the Committee. “What we are missing [in Government statistics and policy packages] is families that have multiple poverty factors. These families need more joined up policy solutions.”

Research on child poverty in the UK draws on data from a number of national surveys.

One of the most important is the Family Resources Survey (FRS), a continuous UK household survey income that collects detailed information on housing, caring responsibilities, pension, level of savings, childcare, use of food banks and more.

The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) uses the FRS to produce its annual Households Below Average Income (HBAI) statistics

Another key data source is Understanding Society, a long-running longitudinal study that follows the same individuals and families over time. This allows researchers to examine how families’ circumstances change and to identify those experiencing persistent poverty. The DWP also draws on this type of longitudinal evidence in its annual Income Dynamics statistics.

Dr Barnes told the joint Committee that he hopes to see the strategy include targets to tackle child poverty, including targets for persistent poverty, and for deep and complex poverty.

He argued that, without these additional measures, it will be harder to assess whether policy is reaching families experiencing the most entrenched forms of poverty.

The Centre for Poverty and Innovation

The Centre for Poverty and Innovation is co-led by Dr Barnes and Dr Haseeb Shabbir, Reader in Voluntary Sector Management, and is currently in its set-up phase.

It is an academically independent, multi-disciplinary initiative focused on deep and complex poverty. The Centre generates practice-relevant evidence and works with partners across policy, practice and communities to support more effective responses to poverty.